by Florian Städtler, Vocal Blog founder – inspired by Andrea Figallo (Wise Guys)
Andrea Figallo is one of the most active, communicative, polyglot and sometimes provocative vocal music pros in Europe. His singing and beatboxing with The Flying Pickets and the German vocal supergroup Wise Guys (to name only a very few of his activities) has made him travel the world. His having Japanese in-laws even more opened up his eyes for different mindsets, habits and intercultural differences. No wonder, he reacted promptly when I tweeted about his new group’s relationship (or should I say non-relationship?) to the so-called a cappella community. It only took minutes and we were in the middle of discussing the ever-present “Big Questions” that always come up when we try to reflect on “vocal music”.
Andrea took the question of the relevance of original music to Facebook and in a few minutes again, nerds and “normal people” from Italy, Germany, Hungary and elsewhere started to add interesting points and opinions on multiple topics. I personally find the real time thread technique on Facebook fascinating, on the other hand, sometimes confusing and unefficient. So, having the luxury of a blog of my own, I decided to dig the nugget topics (“BigQs”) out of the mud of spontaneous interaction, reflect on them in order to create a starting point for a discussion and then invite both experts and the “John & Jane Doe” music listener to give their opinions on clearly defined questions.
I’ve gathered 9 basic questions as of today and would be delighted if you would add more or more specific questions to complete the debate. I hope to end up with something fascinating and priceless as “The Great A Cappella Debate” two years ago, when a Facebook post by Californian aca-fan Nate George about the wrong impression The Sing-off (season 1) gave about US vocal music caused one of most insightful discussions about a cappella I’ve yet come to see. We had people from more than 15 countries and members of Take Six, The Swingle Singers, The King’s Singers, The House Jacks as well as Deke Sharon and other people involved in The Sing-off giving their opinions and thoughts. Let’s hope this draft list will trigger something similar – it’s up to you!
How about a proper crowdsourcing project (bring on your opinions, your thoughts and theories!) combined with a serious attempt to research what has been said/blogged about these matters before and then summing it up in the first white paper/ebook? This digital summary will present the possible answers to the BigQs of a cappella and could be updated annually.So here is a first BigQ list of what from my experience most of us have discussed with different people and different outcomes more than once:
- What exactly is a cappella?
- How important are originals for vocal music?
- What makes (a cappella music) innovative?
- Does being innovative say anything about quality?
- Is there any connection between being innovative and being a mainstream success?
- What is mainstream success from the a cappella point of view?
- What would mainstream success mean for the a cappella community?
- Does the community want this kind of success (and its consequences) after all?
- Do vocal music nerds suffer from an a cappella reality distortion field?
Those who have read Douglas Adams’ clever, extremely funny and thoughtful book(s) “The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy” remember that the adventures of his heroes are closely connected to the hilarious quest for the answer to “The Ultimate Question – The Question of Life, the Universe and Everything”. The people who desperately wanted to know this answer waited 7.5 million years until a supercomputer their ancestors had programmed came up with the answer, which went like this: 42. That’s when they had to build another, even bigger computer to figure out what the actual question was.
So please, before I’m going to start the discussion with presenting the results of my research and some humble thoughts by myself, give me more, better, more precise and more inspiring questions. Questions which, once being answered, give you more certainty, energy and time to concentrate on what really counts: Doing things, implementing plans, writing music, composing originals, pushing your act, getting things done.
Good work and a better life starts with clear thinking. Let’s clarify a few things here during the next two weeks.
I’m Florian Städtler, age 42 (!) and passionate about a cappella. Being founder of my own artist booking agency SpielPlanVier, of my global vocal music conversation baby Vocal Blog and the first professional special interest online shop for all things a cappella, Acappellazone as well as Chairman of the Board of The European Voices Association (EVA), I have decided not be satisfied with my current status quo of half-knowledge. And so 2013 is the first of probably many years on the way to true mastery and insight in that peculiar music business niche we call a cappella, vocal or rhythmic choral music. Looking forward to an exciting journey, come on board!